Me personally, I would keep the MB P and get Vokey SM6 52°, 56° & 60°.

That's the set up I have now with the 714s and SM4s

I went to a Vokey 46 this year and love it!!!

I have 4-pw in the MB's then 52 , 56 and 60

I'd say its mostly personal preference but if you wear out the PW quickly compared to the other irons then I'd go with the Vokey 46/48.

I guess it would depend on how you use your PW.. I personally carry 2PWs in my 4 wedge set, AP2-45°, and vokey sm5 48°bent to 49°. The AP2 is my 140 yard club, my sm5 spins so much it wont carry more than 125 yds. So it's perfect for chipping fast & firm greens because i know it make my PROv1x check up no matter what. Good luck..

I changed from the MP-5 PW to the SM6 46* F.
In June, and never looked back.
I kept the 46* stock shaft in, thought I would have to change over to the 6.0 shaft in. Never did, and gained 5 to 8 yards from the fairway.

I use a Vokey 46.

I think it really comes down to how you use the club. For me, the PW is used generally as a full shot club so I prefer it to match the remainder of my irons. I move into the Vokeys for shots that require much more feel and for shots where I tend to vary the swing speed and face angle more to hit a desired type of shot.

Really appreciate this feedback. I also use my PW primarily with a full swing.

I game the cb's 3-pw and have switched to a 46* adjusted to a 47* vokey sm6 f grind and I love it. Have more control and like the spin I get off the vokey wedge more. Personally I'm happy with my switch.

I play 714s and went to the 46* Bob Voke this season. I like the improved accuracy but it took some time to adjust from losing 5 yds (135 vs 140 with the the stock P wedge). In the end I would recommend the 46*.

Thanks for the feedback guys!!!

I debated the same when I got my 716 AP2. I bent my 48 to 46 to go with 52,56 and 60 and went with 4-9. I feel more comfortable with the Volkey SM5 in hand inside 140.

Vokey spins too much for me to get enough carry. Also inherently doesn't fly quite as far. I stuck with MB PW and then vokey 48 because I hit about 10 yard difference between them.

I think it all comes down to personal preference. I play ap2 irons and opted for the Vokey 46 wedge. I think the Vokey has a little bit more feel than the standard wedge that comes with the set.

Nobody is talking about the bounce of the Wedges I like to vary my wedges between 4* and 12

I think this depends on what your game plan is with the PW in hand. I bought both and I found the MB PW is better for full swing distance consistency. But in my game I rarely full swing any wedges so I have the SM6 in my bag. It's easier to control flights/distance on half/three quarter swings with the Vokey in my opinion. Just depends on your style of play.

I've just made the switch this year from the AP2 PW to the Vokey. I made the switch after converting my Gap,Sand, and Lob wedges from SM 5 to 6. I really liked the feel if the SM 6 in these 3 and decided to switch over the PW as well. I did have the same shafts as my iron set (C taper) installed all the way down to the sw.

In both cases I'm very satisfied. I love the Vokey 46 as my PW. Both the "solid" feel and the mental aspect of having a Vokey in my hand (my brain says " you're supposed to hit these close!") make this a winner for me. I highly recommend it.

The wedge question...for me it's still unanswered. I keep 6 in the car but only 3 in the bag, I would keep the 716s and add to the set. If you can play often you'll find the need for a 52, 54,56,58,60. Additionally if you have a wedge you like now keep it I have some going back into the early 80's...Good luck

I currentl use 714 AP2 4i-AW. I use Vokey SM5 54° and 58°. I'm going to switch to a Vokey 50° next season but have also wondered what the benefit is to swapping out my PW. Interested to follow this thread!

Thanks guys you've answered my question. I have SM6 50/56/60 and they are the prettiest and nicest clubs I've ever had. I'll get the 46 as well. My real question is will Titleist ask Bob V to make a full set of irons from 3 right through. That would be a premium set